The accused pleaded guilty to four indictable animal cruelty offences arising from his treatment of four puppies, each approximately eight to ten weeks old. Over several months, he acquired puppies from different sellers; one was later found dead and covered in blood, while the other three were found abandoned with severe mutilations to their noses and, in two cases, their tongues. The Court found the conduct was repeated and planned, involved exceptionally vulnerable animals, caused permanent injuries, and constituted a serious breach of trust.
Victim impact statements submitted by those who had cared for the three surviving puppies – Foster, Sunny and Lenny – “described the puppies’ acute pain, permanent physical limitations and continuing fear, as well as the demanding medical and emotional responsibilities assumed by their caregivers” (para. 41). The Court found that the “statements as a whole establish that the harm did not end when the puppies were found” and would persist in their disabilities as well as in the caregivers’ emotional and practical burdens of caring for them (para. 48).
The Court emphasized that deliberate physical attacks on animals are crimes of violence and that denunciation and deterrence are primary sentencing objectives in animal cruelty cases. It quoted Chen in the analysis of sentencing principles and authorities, acknowledging that animals are sentient beings capable of experiencing pain and suffering, and “are vulnerable because they are under the control of human caretakers and are unable to communicate their suffering” para. 54). Aggravating factors included the number and vulnerability of the animals, repeated and planned conduct, permanent injuries, abandonment, breach of trust, and the commission of the offences while the accused was subject to a release order on an unrelated charge. Mitigating factors included early guilty pleas, no prior criminal record, apparent shame and remorse, family support, prospects for rehabilitation, and particularly harsh presentence custody conditions where the accused had been assaulted.
The Crown sought a global sentence of four years’ imprisonment, less credit for presentence custody, while defence counsel was seeking time served after credit for presentence custody, with the four animal cruelty counts treated as concurrent.
The accused received concurrent sentences amounting to 725 days’ imprisonment (two years less five days). With enhanced credit for 483 days of presentence custody, the sentence was satisfied by time served. The Court also imposed a lifetime prohibition on owning, having custody or control of, or residing with an animal or bird; ordered $29,772.49 in restitution to the City of Mississauga for veterinary and related care, and made a DNA order. The animal prohibition order was deemed necessary because the accused had “deliberately acquired several young puppies from different sellers over several months. The offences were repeated, involved a serious breach of trust and caused permanent injuries” (para. 99).
