On May 23, 2023, complaints of animal abuse were made against the appellant by his neighbours, who provided an Animal Welfare Services (AWS) Inspector with video evidence showing him repeatedly striking his five dogs with his hands, fists, and a flashlight—once in front of a child (paras 20–21). After reviewing the videos, an AWS consulting veterinarian identified clear signs of physical and psychological distress and recommended removing the dogs from Henry’s care to alleviate their suffering.
A signed Veterinarian’s Certificate was subsequently provided on May 30, 2023, supporting their removal (para 20).Four adult dogs and a puppy were removed from the appellant’s care on May 31, 2023, by an AWS Inspector acting under a warrant pursuant to s. 31 of the Provincial Animal Welfare Services Act, 2019, S.O. 2019, c. 13 (the “PAWS Act”). The appellant was issued a Notice of Removal (NOR) (paras 1–2).
On June 4, 2023, the appellant was served with a Notice of Decision to Keep an Animal in the Chief Animal Welfare Inspector’s Care (DTK). On June 5, 2023, he appealed the NOR to the Animal Care Review Board (ACRB), requesting the return of his five dogs, but did not appeal the DTK (paras 3–4). He argued that his actions were legitimate training methods and challenged the reliability and context of the videos (paras 12, 24–25, 33).
The ACRB dismissed the appellant’s appeal, finding that the dogs were experiencing physical and psychological distress. The Board determined that their removal was lawful and necessary to alleviate their distress and refused to order their return (paras 31–32, 45–46). The ACRB noted that because the appellant neither appealed the DTK nor applied for the dogs’ return under s. 38(4) of the PAWS Act, it lacked jurisdiction to order their return on those grounds. Nevertheless, the Board found that even if such an application had been made, the dogs should not be returned because the appellant failed to provide evidence that the conditions causing their distress ben remedied (paras 35, 44).
The decision highlights that animal distress under the PAWS Act includes psychological suffering (paras 18–19). The dogs’ fearful behaviours, including cowering, fleeing, and hypervigilance, supported the finding of distress (paras 21, 27–28). Additionally, veterinary evidence indicated that the dogs could continue experiencing psychological distress if returned to Henry, even if the physical abuse stopped (paras 37–38, 43).