It was alleged that the accused had wilfully caused unnecessary pain, suffering or injury to his fiancee’s dog when he kicked the dog, slammed their head into the elevator door three times, then flicked their leash at their head, and flipped the animal in a way which caused them to tumble, during the course of a short elevator ride. The primary evidence before the Court was a 60 second elevator video, 45 seconds of which captured the incident.
The Court was satisfied that accused’s conduct was wilfull and possessed the necessary mens rea for the offence. The Court accepted that there was no injury to the dog based on other non-expert evidence provided by the animal welfare officer who attended the scene. The issue before the Court was whether accused’s actions caused the dog unnecessary pain or suffering.
In its analysis on the law, the Court began with a statement quoting Chen: “The Court of Appeal of this Province has noted recently that animals, including dogs, are sentient… beings, capable of feeling and experiencing sensations and emotions, including feeling pain and suffering” (p.5).
The Court held that proving beyond a reasonable that some pain or suffering beyond “the least physical discomfort” occurred is sufficient to then consider whether the pain or suffering was unnecessary. Case law supported the ability of the trier of fact to infer pain and suffering from the evidence. Despite accepting the accused’s point that there had been no expert testimony provided, the judge indicated “that does not mean that based upon what I can see and hear on the elevator video, using common sense and experience, I am not able to conclude beyond a reasonable doubt that the dog sustained pain and suffering” (p. 8).
While the Court did not find that the leash flick caused unnecessary pain and the dog’s tumble was actually caused by the accused, it was objectionably foreseeable that the kicking and slamming would cause the dog unnecessary pain or suffering. Based on the dog’s reactions, the pain or suffering went beyond “the least physical discomfort.” It determined that these actions were done intentionally to cause the dog pain, and they were unnecessary.
The Court found the accused guilty of the offence charged.
