The offender pleaded guilty to animal cruelty for wilfully permitting his cat to experience unnecessary pain and suffering. The cat suffered serious injuries over approximately two to three weeks, but the offender attempted to treat him himself rather than seeking veterinary care, claiming that he could not afford veterinary treatment because of his severe addiction to cocaine and opioids. The cat’s injuries were so serious that he eventually had to be euthanized.
The offender also pleaded guilty to several unrelated property offences, including fraud, theft, and breaches of court orders. He had a limited criminal record (one past DUI conviction) and struggled with substance abuse of illicit drugs.
The Ontario Court of Justice sentenced the offender to a global sentence of 12 months’ imprisonment, followed by two years of probation, taking into account his pretrial custody and other offences. For the animal cruelty offence specifically, the judge determined that a four-month custodial sentence was appropriate, crediting three months for time already served and ordering an additional 30 days in jail.
The judge emphasized that the offender had allowed his cat to suffer unnecessarily for several weeks despite having the option of surrendering him to the SPCA. The court also imposed a seven-year prohibition order preventing him from owning, caring for, controlling, or living with animals. The judge considered his limited criminal history and relatively low risk of reoffending when determining the length of the prohibition and determined that the seven-year prohibition order demonstrates the importance of preventing future animal suffering, even if the offender is considered to have a relatively low risk of reoffending.
