R. v. Dominic., 2009 BCPC 145

The accused was charged under section 445(a) of the Criminal Code with wilfully and without lawful excuse killing a dog kept for a lawful purpose. On May 28, 2007, he was heavily intoxicated when he stomped twice on a small dog belonging to a woman he had been drinking with, then picked him up and threw him to the ground, killing him. The accused did have a criminal history that was not specified in the judgment.

A neighbour witnessed the incident and contacted the police. The accused claimed that he had consumed significant amounts of alcohol and could not remember attacking the dog. Defence counsel argued that his intoxication prevented him from forming the criminal intent necessary for a conviction.

The British Columbia Provincial Court found the accused guilty of wilfully killing the dog under section 445(a). The court accepted that the accused had been heavily intoxicated but rejected the claim that he was so impaired that he could not control his actions ‘akin to automatism” (para. 76(c)) and noted that he had demonstrated an ability to make various decisions that evening despite his intoxication. The judge concluded that the accused was in a state of advanced intoxication, rather than extreme intoxication comparable to automatism.

Since section 445(a) was classified as a general intent offence, advanced intoxication could not serve as a defence. The court also determined that the dog’s death was a natural consequence of the accused’s voluntary actions. This case establishes that wilfully killing a dog under section 445(a) of the Criminal Code is a general intent offence in such that advanced intoxication cannot excuse criminal responsibility.