This was a sentencing hearing after the accused plead guilty to a charge under s. 21(1) of Animal Protection Act.
The accused forcefully struck the dog 14 times after she caused him to spill his coffee, which was caught on the CCTV in his apartment lobby. The footage showed the dog flenching, cowering, tensing, with her tail down and ears back. While dog showed no outward signs of physical injury, an animal behaviour and welfare scientist provided an expert opinion that the dog was suffering psychological pain and anxiety.
The accused was very remorseful and the guilty plea was considered a significant mitigating factor. The court accepted the joint recommendation put forth by the Crown and defence and order a $1000 fine and a three-year prohibition order.